| Wrestler | Event Won At | Date | Length of Reign | Notes |
| Steve Rogers | Showtime I | December 28, 1994 | 24 days | Won in a tournament final over Mud Monster |
| Lorenzo Vasquez | EMWC Saturday Night | January 21, 1995 | 123 days | |
| Narcissus | Rumble In The Windy City | May 24,1995 | 48 days | |
| Roscoe Law | Cross The Border | July 11, 1995 | 124 days | |
| Trey Porter | No Imitations Accepted ’95 | November 12, 1995 | 84 days | |
| Olaf Proet | Rumble In The Sunshine State | February 4, 1996 | 0 days | |
| Todd Michaelson | Rumble In The Sunshine State | February 4, 1996 | 0 days |